Value (First Lean Principle)concept

mudalean-thinkingfive-principlescustomer-value
1 min read · Edit on Pyrite

The first of the five-lean-principles: define value from the customer's perspective. james-p-womack and daniel-t-jones placed this as the starting point of lean thinking in lean-thinking (1996), arguing that all lean efforts must begin by specifying what the customer actually wants.

The Reframing

taiichi-ohno's TPS began with waste — the seven types of muda — and worked to eliminate them. This is a subtractive approach: identify what shouldn't be there and remove it. Womack and Jones inverted the logic: begin by defining what should be there (value), then identify everything that isn't value (waste). The practical effect is the same — waste gets eliminated — but the starting point changes the conversation from "what's wrong?" to "what does the customer need?"

This inversion was aimed at Western managers. Ohno could assume Toyota's workforce understood the customer's requirements implicitly through decades of organizational culture. Womack and Jones could not make that assumption for the diverse organizations they were addressing. By making value definition the explicit first step, they forced the question: "Do we actually know what our customer values?"

Application

In practice, the value principle asks organizations to:

  • Specify value in terms of a specific product or service with specific capabilities at a specific price, as perceived by the customer
  • Challenge internal definitions of value that serve organizational convenience rather than customer needs
  • Recognize that most organizations define value from their own perspective (cost reduction, asset utilization) rather than the customer's
  • The principle's downstream application in healthcare (patient-defined value), software (user-defined value), and services (consumer-defined value through lean-consumption) all trace from this starting point.

    Research Needed

  • How Womack/Jones arrived at the customer-first framing versus Ohno's waste-first framing
  • Whether the value principle draws on marketing theory or quality management (Deming's focus on the customer) in addition to TPS