ILC (Innovate-Leverage-Commoditize)concept

patternawsplatformgameplaycommoditization
2 min read · Edit on Pyrite

Definition

ILC (Innovate-Leverage-Commoditize) is a gameplay pattern identified by Wardley that describes how organizations can systematically create competitive advantage by managing the full evolutionary lifecycle of components. It is one of the most powerful gameplay patterns in the framework.

The Three Phases

Innovate: Create or invest in genesis-stage components — new capabilities that do not yet exist in the market. This is high-risk, high-uncertainty work that requires pioneer-style teams.

Leverage: As the innovation matures (custom-built to product), leverage it for revenue and market position. Build a business around the component at the product stage, where differentiation and margins are highest.

Commoditize: When the component is mature enough, commoditize it — offer it as a utility service at scale. This destroys competitors who are still selling it as a product (they cannot compete with utility pricing and scale), and simultaneously creates a platform on which new genesis-stage innovations can emerge.

The Canonical Example: Amazon Web Services

Amazon Web Services (AWS) is the example Wardley most frequently uses to illustrate ILC. Amazon innovated in e-commerce infrastructure (building computing, storage, and networking capabilities for its own use), leveraged those capabilities to support its retail business, and then commoditized them as utility services (EC2, S3, etc.). The commoditization of infrastructure created a platform on which an entire ecosystem of startups and applications could build — generating new innovation that further increased demand for Amazon's commodity services.

The ILC pattern explains AWS's strategic power: by commoditizing infrastructure, Amazon simultaneously destroyed competitors' ability to differentiate on infrastructure AND created a platform that generates continuous demand for its commodity services.

Strategic Implications

ILC explains several otherwise puzzling corporate strategies:

  • Why Google gives away Android (commoditizing mobile OS to protect search advertising)
  • Why companies open-source software (commoditizing a component to capture value in the layer above)
  • Why cloud providers offer free tiers (accelerating commoditization to capture platform effects)
  • The pattern also explains a common strategic mistake: companies that try to innovate without a plan to leverage and commoditize, or companies that try to commoditize without having first built a position in the higher-order systems that the commodity enables.

    Relationship to Other Concepts

    ILC is a gameplay pattern that requires understanding evolution (knowing where a component is and where it is heading) and the climate pattern that "efficiency enables innovation" (commoditizing one layer enables innovation in the layer above). It is one of the most direct applications of the evolution axis to competitive strategy.