September 11 and the RRE Responsecascade_event

infrastructuresurveillancecivil-liberties9/11wardemocracy
2001-09-14 · 2 min read · Edit on Pyrite

Overview

The September 11, 2001 attacks and their aftermath generated one of the most intense clusters of RRE activity, and produced some of Agre's most significant political writing. Within three days of the attacks, Agre published 'Imagining the Next War: Infrastructural Warfare and the Conditions of Democracy' (September 14, 2001), a 4,300-word essay that brought together his entire intellectual framework to analyze the political meaning of 9/11. A week later he published the expanded 9,500-word version, 'Some Notes on War in a World Without Boundaries' (September 21, 2001).

Key RRE Posts

Agre's own writings (with his bracketed commentary):

  • 'Imagining the Next War' (Sept 14, 2001) — Major essay arguing that boundaryless war is incompatible with democracy and equivalent to conservatism. Proposes 'total security' through infrastructure redesign rather than 'total war.'
  • 'Some Notes on War in a World Without Boundaries' (Sept 21, 2001) — Expanded version adding sections on the war/crime conflation, moral vs practical responsibility, ideological work and the Internet, the discourse of terrorism, and urban design.
  • 'civil liberties emergency' (Sept 24, 2001) — Agre's commentary introducing the 'argument from paperwork' and proposing technological solutions for due process, plus updates to 'Your Face Is Not a Bar Code' with post-9/11 arguments.
  • Curated forwarded material:

  • Special EPIC Alert (Sept 17, 2001) — Congressional statements defending civil liberties
  • Editorials supporting civil liberties (Sept 24, 2001) — Newspaper editorial compilation
  • Update on civil liberties (Sept 25, 2001) — EPIC Alert on anti-terrorism legislation
  • Special issue of Crypto-Gram (Sept 30, 2001) — Bruce Schneier's security analysis
  • RRE links relating to the September 11th attacks (Dec 6, 2001) — Comprehensive compiled links
  • Significance

    This cluster demonstrates Agre at his most powerful as a public intellectual, applying his analytical framework — institutional analysis, democratic design, conservative movement analysis, selective amplification, and surveillance critique — to a real-time political crisis. The speed and depth of 'Imagining the Next War' is remarkable: written 72 hours after the attacks, it anticipated debates about permanent war, the surveillance state, and democratic erosion that would dominate political discourse for decades.