Homelandwriting

fictionsurveillancecivil-libertiesYAwhistleblowingsequel
2013-02-05 · 3 min read · Edit on Pyrite

Homeland (2013) is the direct sequel to little-brother, following Marcus Yallow five years later as he confronts a new surveillance threat — this time involving a trove of leaked documents about government and corporate wrongdoing. Published by tor-books with simultaneous free digital release under creative-commons-licensing, the novel was deliberately timed to engage with the whistleblowing debates that preceded — and then were dramatically amplified by — the edward-snowden revelations of June 2013.

The Snowden Shadow

Homeland was written before the Snowden disclosures but published four months before them. The central plot — Marcus receives a USB drive full of documents proving illegal government surveillance and must decide what to do with them — reads in retrospect as uncanny anticipation. When the NSA documents became public months after the novel's release, Doctorow found himself in the unusual position of having written a novel whose premise had just become news.

The novel's political argument about whistleblowing — that individuals who expose illegal government conduct are performing a public service, that the state's interest in suppressing such exposure is not the same as the public interest, and that the tools and networks that make exposure possible must be protected — became substantially more urgent and mainstream after Snowden. Doctorow has credited the novel's timing as accidental but has engaged extensively with the post-Snowden surveillance debates as public intellectual and electronic-frontier-foundation voice.

Technical Education: Version Two

Like little-brother, Homeland uses Marcus's predicament to teach security and technical concepts. This installment focuses more on the operational security considerations for people handling sensitive documents and communications — essentially a primer on how whistleblowers and journalists protect themselves and their sources. Jacob Appelbaum and Aaron Swartz contributed afterwords.

The inclusion of aaron-swartz is significant and painful. Swartz wrote his afterword for Homeland in late 2012; he died by suicide in January 2013, while facing federal prosecution for downloading academic articles from JSTOR. The novel was published weeks after his death, and Doctorow's dedication and the afterword became a memorial as well as a political statement about the Department of Justice's use of computer crime statutes to punish activists.

Political Maturity

Marcus in Homeland is older and somewhat wiser than in little-brother — less naive about the costs of activism, more aware of the institutional obstacles to change, and more sophisticated about the politics of coalition building. This reflects Doctorow's own evolution as an activist: the optimism of the mid-2000s free culture movement had been tested by SOPA/PIPA, the Digital Economy Act, and the treatment of aaron-swartz and other internet activists.

The novel engages with electoral politics and political campaigning in ways little-brother did not — Marcus goes to work for a politician running on a civil liberties platform and confronts the compromises and disappointments of working within electoral structures. This is more ambivalent territory for Doctorow than the pure civil disobedience of pirate-cinema or the technical resistance of little-brother.

Relationship to Information Doesn't Want to Be Free

Homeland and information-doesnt-want-to-be-free were published in the same period and should be read together as expressions of the same concerns: the political and economic structures that enable surveillance and control of information, and the means available to individuals and communities to resist them. The novel provides the narrative; the nonfiction book provides the analytical framework.

A third book in the Little Brother series, Attack Surface (see attack-surface), was published in 2020 following a different protagonist, Masha, who was a government contractor and surveillance apparatus builder — a more morally complicated perspective than Marcus's pure resistance.